Not every disagreement is an investigation, but some complaints legally require one. Learn how to tell the difference and what a fair process looks like.

Workplace complaints range from minor friction between colleagues to serious allegations of harassment or discrimination. Responding in proportion is essential: under-react and you may breach your legal duties; over-react and you can damage relationships unnecessarily.

Complaints that usually require an investigation

In Ontario, the Occupational Health and Safety Act requires employers to have a workplace harassment program that explains how incidents and complaints will be investigated, and to ensure that an investigation appropriate in the circumstances is conducted. In practice, a formal investigation is generally warranted when a complaint involves:

  • Workplace harassment, including sexual harassment
  • Discrimination related to a protected ground under the Human Rights Code
  • Threats or acts of workplace violence
  • Serious misconduct such as theft, fraud or safety violations
  • Allegations against a senior leader or owner

When an informal approach may be enough

Personality clashes, communication breakdowns or disagreements about workload can often be resolved through a facilitated conversation or mediation. Even so, document what happened and how it was resolved, and be ready to escalate if the situation changes.

What a fair investigation looks like

  • An impartial investigator with no stake in the outcome
  • Prompt action and interim measures to protect people where needed
  • Interviews with the complainant, the respondent and relevant witnesses
  • A review of documents, messages and other evidence
  • Confidentiality, to the extent possible
  • A written report with clear findings based on the evidence

Why many employers use a third party

In a small organization, everyone knows everyone. An internal investigator may be a peer, a friend or the manager of the people involved, which makes neutrality hard to achieve and even harder to demonstrate. An external investigator brings independence and experience, and usually produces a report that carries more weight if the matter is later challenged.

After the investigation

Findings are only the beginning. Employers need to decide on proportionate corrective action, communicate the outcome to the parties as required, and look at what the situation reveals about policies, training or culture. Handled well, even a difficult investigation can strengthen trust in leadership.

This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Employment rules change and depend on your specific circumstances.